What do you think was the greatest challenge for newly

0
(0)

 

What do you think was the greatest challenge for newly independent Latin American nations in establishing their national cultures? Use examples from the learning materials to support your response. 

Submit a well-composed response by writing in the “Reply” section directly below this prompt. If you would like to reply to other people, write in the “Reply” section below their post. 

Protocols:

  1. Produce a substantial response to the given prompt (about 200 words – remember, your post should be detailed and specific enough to demonstrate that you have a thorough understanding of the learning materials, 
  2. Proofread your work. Submit college-level writing.

  

What Led to the Struggle for Independence?

Overview:

By the early 1800s, Spain and Portugal controlled all the lands of Latin America except for a few scattered settlements. They had controlled these colonies for nearly 300 years. Beginning in the late 1700s, discontent with European rule began to grow, and by 1824, most of the colonies had fought wars that freed them from Spanish and Portuguese rule. What led to this quest for independence? Consider:

Secularization & Creole Identity

Enlightenment philosophies of the 1700s in Europe and America questioned conservatism epitomized by colonial rule, the divine right of kings, and the closely interrelated institutions of Church and State. The Enlightenment stressed reason, study and analysis, and natural rights. It emphasized the need to know and understand the natural, physical, economic, and political world here on earth more than metaphysical and religious abstractions of what might lie beyond life on earth. The emphasis on science and nature coincided with a growing appreciation of the wealth and natural wonders of the new world, and how they had for centuries been exploited and pillaged to serve the empires of the Old World.

Plaza de Armas luego de la firma de la declaratoria de la independencia el 15 de septiembre de 1821 by Rafael Beltranena, 1910

After two hundred years of living in the new world and intermixing with its original inhabitants, the European descendants (or criollos) began to form societies of people who, although they shared a common language with their European ancestors, were becoming increasingly distinct from them. These emerging societies became more autonomous linguistically, economically , and socially; creating their own sense of reality which did not necessarily coincide with that prevalent in Europe. This feeling of pride in one’s American land and roots grew into regional pride and a nativism that reinforced the notion that Americans (and especially the creoles) were just as good, if not better, than the Europeans.

Nativism & Liberalism

After 300 years of life in the Americas, criollos considered themselves “Americans” and not European. Generations of European descendants had been born and raised in the Americas without any relationship to their “European cousins.”  That is not to say that the criollos had much in common with indigenous, African or mixed raced people of the Americas either. But in a sense, they played second fiddle to the Peninsulares, a term given to those born on the Iberian Peninsula, and so stood to gain from independence. The Peninsulares were not truly interested in helping the masses economically or in terms of equality, so instead, the criollos would now rule Latin America themselves. By stressing birthplace, however, it created a unifying cause. This nativism then was married with liberalism, or rule by the people, to appeal to the masses.

In general, independence movements did little to change the lives of the masses. In a sense it was the “same bus with just a different driver.” Now the criollos ruled in the same way the Peninsulares had for three centuries. However, the seed had been planted for social change.

Post-Independence Challenges

Political Instability & The Caudillo

Events in Europe at the turn of the 19th century greatly influenced events in Latin America. Thanks to Carlos IV, who was basically an absentee ruler, Spain was almost bankrupt in the late 1700s. This led to higher taxes and corruption. The war with England was a further strain on Spain’s economy. As well, The French Revolution of the 1790s inspired many around the world to question the divine right of kings and rule by kings who were in power only because of their pedigree. The battle cry was popular sovereignty. Once obtained, independence unfortunately did not match the promises of popular governance. Old hierarchical structures remained in place. The language and laws of the Iberian colonizers became those of the new nations, and those at the bottom were essentially the labor force for those economically empowered as was the case prior to independence.

Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna by Carlos Paris, 19th Century, Mexican caudillo, CC Wikimedia Commons

The new question facing Latin America was what kind of political system were the new nations going to put in place. The new nations had little or no experience with democracy prior to independence. Political theorists and lawyers had read a lot about the French and U.S. revolutions and would attempt to put similar constitutions in place. However, they had very little knowledge about how they worked. This led to a period of instability lasting about 50 years.

In the power vacuum that had been created, often times military leaders became political leaders. Unfortunately, military skills were often quite different from skills needed by the new constitutions and political theories. These leaders often ruled with a heavy authoritarian hand, and this begins Latin America’s long experience with the caudillo, the strongman who frequently governed like a dictator. The caudillos allied themselves with the landowners and with the Church. For many years, this alliance ruled Latin American politics.

Devastated Economies

As with most war-torn nations, independence struggles had devastating effects on Latin America’s infrastructure and economy. Many industries were destroyed and European moneylenders were busy with other European countries and the United States, making money scarce in the newly independent nations. In addition, there was no transportation infrastructure to handle the high volume of trading that would now be needed. Prior to independence, trade had been on a much smaller scale. Moving products on a large scale from the interior to the coasts for shipping would become a challenge.

The Spanish-Caribbean Remains Spanish Much Longer

Spain did not lose full control over its remaining Caribbean colonies until the end of the 1800s. The Dominican Republic did not fully cut ties with Spain until its second war for independence in 1865. After a few attempts at liberation, both Cuba and Puerto Rico received U.S. intervention in the Spanish-American war of 1898, resulting in Cuba becoming a U.S. protectorate until its full independence in 1902. Puerto Rico remains a U.S. territory today. Considering Cuba and Puerto Rico, revolutionary literature is quite popular with writers during the independence and post-independence eras as you will see in some examples in this and the next module. 

One writer,  the poet Lola Rodríguez de Tió (who we will further discuss in this module), wrote the poem “To Cuba” in 1893 to express the solidarity between the two islands–their shared culture and their longing for freedom:

“To Cuba”

Cuba y Puerto Rico son
de un pájaro las dos alas,
reciben flores o balas
sobre el mismo corazón …

Cuba and Puerto Rico are
As two wings of the same bird,
They receive flowers or bullets
Into the same heart …

 

Arts and Independence

Just as Latin American colonies were trying to exert their autonomy and unique identities through revolutions for independence, the cultural expressions during this time reflected these themes as well. We will now explore a few examples from the arts and literature, starting with the visual arts.

Visual Arts in the 19th Century

At the beginning of the century formats and functions were purely European. Paintings were created using oils on canvases  and were displayed in frames; work of this type had of course existed in Latin America since the Spanish Conquest. By the end of the nineteenth century religious art of the type made for churches had almost died out, and paintings were made just as they were in Europe: either as collectors’ pieces or large scale for display in museums and official buildings of various types. Sculpture was devoted to the commemoration of significant national events and the personification of civic virtues or served as a memorial to national heroes or to civic or military leaders. Often these functions overlapped.

In the mid-19th century, Mexico expressed itself in art through works such as The Tlaxcotlan General Tlahuitcole doing Battle at the Gladiator’s Stone of Sacrifice, a sculpture by the Catalan immigrant Manuel Vilar (1812-59) and The Discovery of Pulque, an historical composition by the Mexican painter Jose Obregon (1832-1902). Both show inspiration of European ideals, particularly Romanticism, adapted to suit American historical themes.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

The information that is gathered every day in healthcare drives

0 (0) The information that is gathered every day in healthcare drives patient care and the improvement of the quality of care. Each staff member within a healthcare institution has a role in improving patient care. In this short paper, complete the following:  Chief of Medicine Managers: Identifies a

Create a nutritional care plan for your client.(old- malnutrition)

0 (0) Create a nutritional care plan for your client.(old- malnutrition) This will include an evaluation of nutritional risk, a list of interventions, and a list of expected outcomes. List the goals of medical nutrition therapy for your patient and suggest an appropriate diet. Does your patient/client require a dietary

Introduction Jones Carolyn Denise is 35 years an old female with

0 (0) Introduction       Jones Carolyn Denise is 35 years an old female with a height of 162.6cm ( 5’4”) and weight of 108kg ( 237 lb ) with a medical condition of acid reflex and Vitamin D deficiency. Mrs. Jones was admitted on February 7, 2023, with a diagnosis of

5 questions to answer separately! All relate to Implementing the ABCDE

0 (0) 5 questions to answer separately! All relate to Implementing the ABCDE Bundle to decrease hospital length of stay in a long-term acute care hospital. You may reference the three primary articles attached – must read them to use them   question 1 Describe the primary quantitative literature upon which

Scientific Study Analysis Prior to beginning work on this assignment,

0 (0) Scientific Study Analysis Prior to beginning work on this assignment, read the article The Relationship Between Multiple Forms of Discrimination, Neighborhood Characteristics, and Depression Among Illicit Drug Users in New York CityLinks to an external site. and address the following questions in a three to four page (excluding title and

How will you use the processes from ARDP 6-22 to improve the ABCT and

0 (0) What is the critical leadership problem facing the 4th ABCT? How will you use the processes from ARDP 6-22 to improve the ABCT and achieve your vision? Clearly and comprehensively explain, defend, and justify your answer. If something is not your original thought, you need to cite your

Early Childhood and Special Education Lesson Plan

0 (0) All materials needed for the lesson must be used or referred to during the PPT presentation including anchor charts, visual supports and manipulatives needed for the presentation. So please take a picture of materials yo used, and also make anchor charts… What you need to do is a

Research the differences in conducting business in the Dominican

0 (0) Research the differences in conducting business in the Dominican Republic as compared to the United States. Consider culture, customs, predominate religions, type of government, natural resources, infrastructure, modes of shipping, stability of economy, currency used internationally, trade relationships/agreements with the United States, living/working conditions, restrictions placed on foreign

Brand Assessment & Shopping Research Paper

0 (0) At the beginning of the assignment due class session, submit a summary of your research compared to your experience in physically visiting and shopping in a retail business. Discuss the business’s strengths and weaknesses in the branding factors you have learned in this course-to-date (class lectures and reading

Nonverbal Research Paper

0 (0) General Instructions Conduct a participant observation of nonverbal communication during a structured period of time (e.g., sitting at a café, during a sports event, while at work, at the gym, etc.). Take field notes throughout the course of your observation. Spend time looking through your field notes and

Marketing – Search Engine Optimization (Footer Writing)

0 (0) Write a Footer for 5 different web pages. Each footer should be approximately 330 words. The footer should briefly describe the Brand and what type of products the brand is selling, and how those products can benefit the customer. There is no specific paper format. Make sure that

a firm/company/store, identifying its product or service, and

0 (0) The project consists of selecting a firm/company/store, identifying its product or service, and analyzing its current market environment. This includes identifying competitors, analyzing nature of the product or service, and examining ease of entry into or exit from the market. It involves examining the market demand and supply,

WNEU ME 322 Spring 2019 Take‐Home Project

0 (0) Find 2 manufacturers within 25 miles of your home town or the town you would like to live in after graduation.  For each manufacturer, gather and compare the following information (as much as is available publicly, or with a little digging – a polite email and/or phone call and/or

Accounting for the iPhone at Apple Inc

0 (0) Please answer 3 case Questions: 1. Compared to the typical point-of-sale accounting method, what are likely effects on income statement, balance sheet, and statement of cash flow of Apple’s choice to use a subscription method for revenue recognition for its iPhone? Also discuss advantages and disadvantages of subscription

IBM Financial Reporting and Analysis

0 (0) Please answer the 19 questions listed below. The questions below are based on the 2017 financial statements of IBM which I provided as a pdf. (Page number references below refer to document page numbers, not .pdf page numbers.) Please only use the financial statements provided to answer the

Proving the Existence of the Traditional Judeo-Christian God

0 (0) You must write about the following 6 items below and defend your thesis. You must explain them all in detail in section 2 of your paper and then critically discuss each of them in section 3 using separate paragraphs. Use paragraphs — at least one for each idea.

Analysis and Presentation of Data

0 (0) Resources: Ch. 15, 16, & 17 of Business Research Methods (all chapters will be attached). Review question four in the “Discussion Questions” of Chapter 15; review question 4 in the “Discussion Questions” of Chapter 16; and review question 10 in the “Discussion Questions” of Chapter 17 of Business

Social and Professional Issues in Computing

0 (0) Select five from the following seven vocations. Which ones do you believe are a true “profession”? Briefly defend your position for each one with facts and references to definitions of a profession from sources such as authors and philosophers. Consider certification, licensing, codes of ethics, education, and enforcement