(Answered) To what extent do you think Jonathan Turner’s (1985; 1992) defence of ‘positivist’ social science is successful?


Overview: Jonathan Turner is a prominent American sociologist, who is known for his contributions to the history of sociology, the sociology of religion and of emotions, and to the general theoretical practice of sociology, in the mid to late 20th century. Turner also defends the a form of ‘positivism’ in the social sciences, arguing that it is the positivist approach to sociology that secures its status as a science, notwithstanding the differences between methods and theories employed in the social and natural sciences. In several articles (Turner, 1985; Turner, 1992), Turner directly defends the legacy and contemporary contributions of positivism to social science from a variety of criticisms. In this essay, you will be discussing various criticisms of the ‘positivist’ approach to social science, and looking at the way that Turner responds to those criticisms. You will need to decide if you generally agree with Turner and his ‘positivist’ sociology, or if you are persuaded by the critics of contemporary positivist social science.  


What you need to do in this essay: This essay can be broken down into four main ‘tasks’:  

Accurately summarise Turner’s views of ‘positivism’ (paying attention to his definition of positivism, his views on ‘science’, his concept of scientific theory, his ideas about theoretical and historical explanations) and his responses to criticisms of positivist social science.

Accurately summarise the criticisms of positivism put forward by Bryant (1992) and Riley (2007), and any other additional criticisms or appraisals of ‘positivist’ social science / sociology you have read in the additional readings;

Clearly identify areas of disagreement (and/ or misunderstanding) between the critics and defenders of positivist social science (these may include, but are not limited to: the definition of positivism; the definition of science and social science; the idea of theory; the use of evidence in the sciences; the applicability of natural scientific method to social science; the real-world ‘effects’ of positivist ideas).

Clearly answer the question: is Turner’s defence of positivism successful? (e.g. is it convincing? Does it show the usefulness of a positivist approach or positivist ideas to contemporary social science? Does it show the criticisms of positivism are wrong?)               



Notes on the Readings:  You are required to read and make reference to the essential readings. These are the two articles by Turner (1985; 1992), and the articles by Bryant (1992) Fuller (1992), and Riley (2007). Note that the three articles – Turner (1992), Bryant (1992) and Fuller (1992) are part of a direct debate about positivism: Bryant’s article is a critique of the ideas of Gerhard Lenski, Guy Swanson and Jonathan Turner; Turner and Fuller then responded to Bryant’s arguments.      


Note on the Additional Readings: Baldus (1990), Howe (2009), Ferrarotti (1999), and Brieschke (1992) all provide criticisms of positivism. Lundberg (1939), Schlick & Rynin (1948/49) and Taube (1937) and Laird (1938-9) give ‘classic’ (non-comtemporary) discussions of positivism, attempting to define and exemplify the positivist approach. Other readings on the list talk about positivism and various philosophical approaches to studying society (see: Rickman, 1960; Oberdan, 1990; Warshay & Warshay, 1987), or positivism as a ‘methodology’ (see: Dugger, 1983; Neufeld, 1993; Chenhall, 1971).     


Essential Readings

Bryant, Joseph M. (1992). ‘Positivism Redivivus? A Critique of Recent Uncritical Proposals for Reforming Sociological Theory (And Related Foibles)’, The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1 (Winter, 1992), pp. 29-53

Fuller, Steve (1992). ‘A Plague on Both Your Houses: Beyond Recidivism in the Sociological Theory Debates’. The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1(Winter, 1992), pp. 62-68

Turner, Jonathan H. (1985). In Defense of Positivism, Sociological Theory, Vol. 3, No. 2 (Autumn, 1985), pp. 24-30

Turner, Jonathan H. (1992). If Not Positivism, Then Why Is Sociology Important? The Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Vol. 17, No. 1 (Winter, 1992), pp. 54-61.

Riley, Dylan (2007). The Paradox of Positivism, Social Science History, Vol. 31, No. 1 (Spring, 2007), pp. 115-126

Click here to request for this assignment help

#extent #Jonathan #Turners #defence #positivist #social #science #successful

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Share This Post


Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

(Answered) Task 2: Argumentative Research Paper- Organic foods verses GMOs

0 (0) Writing a research paper gives you an opportunity to explore a topic of special interest, research that topic, and organize your research findings in writing for an academic audience.   Through your preparation work, you have established an argumentative thesis statement and have planned a clear organization of

(Answered) M3A1: Citizens United

0 (0) (copy and paste the link) Review Campaign Finance: Abuses and Reforms. [Video File] [48 min 25 sec] before you participate in this activity. Parts of the video will discuss aspects of campaign finance and reform. Before engaging in this activity, please return to the first discussion topic on

(Answered) The decision in Williams v Roffey Bros signals that the courts in deciding whether or not to enforce a promise, may be guided less by technical questions of consideration than by questions of fairness, reasonableness and commercial utility.

0 (0) The decision in Williams v Roffey Bros signals that the courts in deciding whether or not to enforce a promise, may be guided less by technical questions of consideration than by questions of fairness, reasonableness and commercial utility.   The assignment will be in accordance with the following

(Answered) What are the effects of Ketamine treatment on treatment resistant depression?

0 (0) • Introductory statement clearly describes the phenomenon and main health issue • Clearly identifies the problem and gives an argument for examining the problem • Thesis statement is clear and well-articulated • Clearly articulates the particular population with clinical setting provided 1. Operational Definitions • Operational definitions of

(Answered) Management and Organizational Behavior.

0 (0) Description Exercise 17: Read Annual Pay Raises (W-68-69). This is located in the color-coded workbook section in the back of your book. ( Uhl-Bien, M., Osborn, R. N., & Schermerhorn, J. R. (2014).) Organizational Behavior. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. ISBN:9781118517376 Review the exercise and complete steps 1 and 2.

(Answered) The Wall of Silence Reflective Journal

0 (0)  Assignment Instructions: For this course, you will be reading The Wall of Silence by Gibson and Singh (2003). Please read the book and reflect upon what you have read, and complete the assignment as described. The purpose of this reflective assignment is to provide the approach for connecting


0 (0) Determination of Human Subjects Research Form and my project proposal. please, research about IRB. write the Description. Referencing the Determination Checklist on Page 2, briefly describe project objectives, the subject population and types of data/specimens to be collected and analyzed, how the data/specimens will be obtained, and why

(Answered) Company Description and SWOT

0 (0) Non Alcoholic Beverage company!!!! n this assignment, you will conduct a SWOT (Strength, Weakness, Opportunity, and Threat) analysis for the type of beverage you have selected, and for your company overall. As you work on the assignment, consider why you have chosen one type of non-alcoholic beverage over

(Answered) Oral Language chart of phone conversation

0 (0) Instructions In an APA formatted paper, paste the template found in doc. sharing. Define each of the terms and then watch the video of two children talking on the phone. Rate the language development of one of the two children in the video found at Use the SOLOM.

(Answered) Motivations of Private-Sector Organizations

0 (0)  Presidential Policy Directive 8 (PPD-8) is part of the national preparedness goal and provides a description for preparing for the threats in an all-hazards approach that pose the greatest risk to the United States. Community preparedness is a shared responsibility of the whole community. In addition to the

(Answered) Effective Resource Allocation

0 (0)  The discussion assignment for this week includes a review of the Key Assignment Outline completed by one of your classmates, as well as a substantial response to at least one other student. Primary Task Response: Your first task is to post your own Key Assignment Outline to the

(Answered) Ethics Case Study

0 (0) A student’s analysis of the ethic case must use the following written structural framework, which can be written as a memorandum to the file. Without the bullet points – these indicate required headings for each of the four sections. The following the description heading below to form a

(Answered) The Relativist Ethical Position.

0 (0)  In your post, address the following: To what extent would you agree with the view that research should rely on a relativist ethical position—rules or duties may vary across different communities and professional groups? What examples could you suggest to support this view? References: – Doing Research in

(Answered) Poverty in the classroom

0 (0) A four-unit research paper in APA formatting centered around the effects of poverty in education. The first unit needs to be about the effects poverty has on students in the classroom and needs to be 8-10 pages. Second unit is on the effects of substance abuse on students

(Answered) Causes of America’s War in Vietnam

0 (0) Description Formatting 12 font or smaller, standard script (e.g. Calibri, New Times Roman), 1.00-1.25 margins maximum, double spaced, clean appearance, etc. Basic organization is simple— don’t make it difficult Title— choose one that reflects your views on the topic to inform and engage your reader from the start,

(Answered) Workflows in telemetry

0 (0) Workflow analysis aims to determine workflow patterns that maximize the effective use of resources and minimize activities that do not add value. There are a variety of tools that can be used to analyze the workflow of processes and clarify potential avenues for eliminating waste. Flowcharts are a

(Answered) Critical Decision Making for Providers

0 (0) View the scenario called “Critical Decision Making for Providers”. In a 750-1,200 word paper, describe the scenario involving Mike, the lab technician, and answer the following questions: What were the consequences of a failure to report? What impact did his decision have on patient safety, on the risk